Australian Idol judges at war
Posted at 08:47 on 22 October, 2007
It's war on the Australian Idol judging panel with four judges in three likely seats. Marcia Hines has threatened to quit, while Mark Holden has said Dicko is surplus and that Hines is boring. Who needs to go and why?
| 25 Oct 07
|
I don't like Mark Holden...
Why does everyone say Kyle is a d*ckhead? I think he's just honest.
And I think Dicko gives constructive criticism, which helps the idols.
As for Marcia, 99.99% of her comments are positive...
If anyone leaves, I hope it's Mark Holden. I just like him for his touchdowns (Though the "Touchdown" was used by Paula Abdul in the First Few seasons of American Idol - So it wasn't his idea).
Donatella Versace
|
| 30 Oct 07
|
frankly i think all the hype about the show is stupid. people should get a life.
though at least its better than big brother. that show is so bloody pointless.
bored observer
|
| 1 Nov 07
|
I watc tv beyound tomorow evey week I like you Anna choy ......
I am thailand ....
Nice to meet you ...^-^
Amorn
|
| 2 Nov 07
|
While I admire Mark's passion for the show and I like Marcia, I think Australian Idol would be much better if it replaced these two with someone like Olivia Newton-John and return to the 3 judge format. 4 judges isn't working.
chris
|
| 4 Nov 07
|
i know everyone hates kyle but some of the comments he makes are funny and often true. I like dicko because I really believe his critisism while sometimes harsh is helpful in making the contestants improve. I wouldn't mind if either marcia or mark left but they'd need to find one person equally as dorky as mark and equally as nice and positive as marcia to fill their spot.
l-esky
|
| 4 Nov 07
|
Why isn't this a poll?
Marcia should go as she doesn't give real opinions, and is far too kind.
Dicko next.
Mark also should either go, or at least his ability to make touch downs.
Adrian
|
| 25 Nov 07
|
This show sux, and I can't believe anyone would buy into it.
There's a great wrap-up article here:
http://www.aarondarc.com
Dean
|
